Attendees: Kelley Spoon, Don, Glen, Ben C, Riku, Anton, Glen, Joanna,
Shebu, Dave R, Xinyu
Minutes:
- Glen: Use of staging server?
- Anton: Yes, used by the team. Working well.
- Joanna: Not really using it.
- Glen: Arthur had noticed a glitch in stage where it slowed down so
wanted to check
- Glen: Team noticed Arm copyrights in the Open CI code. Should this be
changed?
- Anton: Perhaps a TSC topic?
- Joanna: For TF-A changes, whoever does the work it's OK w/ copyrights
- Glen to check and see if any agreements outline the plans
- Shebu: What we do with copyrights is up to project
- Ben C: Use reuse <https://reuse.software/> to align the licensing.
Mainly use MIT license
- Joanna: Difference between copyright and licensing. Mainly use BSD
for new contributions
- Glen: Update - Cypress boards planned to go into the lab this week as
well as the first Chromebook (Azura)
- Glen: Update - mbed TLS. Authentication blocker resolved. Ready to
start testing. Expect it to move faster now.
- Dave R: Please keep the updates coming :)
- Glen: Update - Expect scripts/code coverage - Paul working w/ LAVA
team. Lots of code under review so expect something soon.
- Shebu: Code coverage blocked?
- Glen: Yes waiting for the resolution of a LAVA regression. Paul
working this. Can then work on cleaning up output and aggregate outpu.
- Glen: Found some stability issues and fixed those in LAVA.
- Joanna: Compiler license issues impacts?
- Glen: FVP licensing - expired. Contacted Paul Black.
- Glen: Other compilers expire in January, working that as well.
- Shebu: Note compiler and FVP licenses come out of different teams.
- Glen: Paul Black suggested moving to new licensing technology. Not
sure yet on impacts to Open CI. Supposed to improve performance.
- Glen: Need to investigate migration
- Joanna: Change compilers and licensing?
- Glen: Yes, that's believed to be the case. Need to do some research
prior to deploying.
- Glen: Compilers have another month, FVP looks like November 24th
expiration.
- Anton: Staging feedback - works but occasionally has stability issues.
- Xinyu: Get 403 error. Goes away after several refreshes.
- Glen: Saw this last week but then started working.
- Xinyu: Occurring for several months.
- Anton: Plan TF-M release today.
- Joanna: TF-A release was last week
<end>
*Attendees*: Don, Kelley Spoon, Ben C, Xinyu, Matteo, Riku, Joanna, SHebu,
Anton, Riku
*Minutes*:
- Musca-b's received by the lab
- Do existing ones need swapped out?
- Don: If shelf as "hot spares" would like to pull out, configure,
and validate.
- If Musca's continue to fail, need to deep dive on root cause.
- Three were shipped.
- Glen: Create a ticket to configure and validate prior to shelving
as hot spares
- Ben: TFC-200 closed out (inconsistent test results).
- Several tickets to close
- Glen: Issue TFC-199 logged by Joanna. Failed docker builds
- Arm changed compiler release process. Need a new process to get
compilers/docker images.
- Joanna: Options being explored. Automation of login.
- Riku. Arm put this in place to force login to use the tool. We're
doing a work around of their intent
- Glen: Uneasy on storing static versions.
- Joanna: This is all projects, not just TF-A. Immediate issue
resolved
- TFC-93
- Should be getting the 3rd NXP board and needs put into the lab.
- Include in daily runs?
- Xinyu: Already pushed patches to enable NXP in LAVA.
- Anton: Someone from NXP should merge the requests.
- Action: Talk to NXP (Andrej) to get permissions. Once permission,
a PR will need merged (
https://review.trustedfirmware.org/c/ci/tf-m-ci-scripts/+/12584 &
https://review.trustedfirmware.org/c/ci/tf-m-ci-scripts/+/12524 )
- Chromebooks
- Theo has these up and running, will be going into the lab to add
these.
- Cypress: On deck to be added to lab. Assigned to next sprint.
- MBedTLS - Working on installing infrastructure
- Kelly - setting up role strategy plugin for Jenkins. Working on it
now.
- Anton: Tech Forum this Thursday. Will cancel.
<end>
Attendees: Don, Xinyu, Ben, Dave R, Joanna, Riku, Shebu, Anton
Minutes:
- Glen: Adjusted TFC board based on Joanna and Shebu's priority lists.
- In Progress: Leonardo working on TFC-176 and TFC-7
- In Progress: NXP boards are in. Leaving in Progress for now. A
couple tests are still not running, but working thru it.
- Discussed who is responsible when vendor bugs found
- Anton: Maybe a TSC decision
- Shebu: Suggest platform owners. Don't know if written down anywhere.
- Joanna: No TF-A boards in, but when tests failing, need to go back
to the vendor. In some cases, if infrastructure, wouldn't go back to
vendor. If believe it's h/w, then go back to vendor.
- Anton: In TF-M has platform owners documented.
- Shebu: May want to formalize at next Board meeting. Take to TSC as
well. Members need to keep an eye on their h/w.
- What about daily checks?
- Joanna: I do for TF-A. Need escalation route to board owner.
- Shebu: Should Open-CI mailing list add platform owners?
- Anton: Not sure that's the best way. Likely a 1:1 email
- Joanna: Typically sends notes directly to Linaro team or board
owner.
- Glen: This is focused on s/w issues. Pretty good when a hard
failure related to h/w.
- Summary: Notify Board on plans. Team leads already monitor
- Chromebook TFC-45 (Asudra) are being worked on. Next Chromebook was
also received.
- Cypress h/w goes into the next sprint to install
- MBedTLS - transition work from Leonardo to Arthur.
- Also have Riku involved on the authentication model
- STG-2704: Haven't started work yet on this (Roles).
- Joanna: Slowing down builds could cause builds to bump into each other
from different GEO's.
- MBedTLS has been delayed for a while, depending upon confidence level.
- Anton: Thanks to the Open CI team for getting the Musca-b's back
online. More boards coming to Linaro.
- Glen: Paul Black from Arm reached out about changing compiler
licensing. Will need to understand this. Glen to create a new TFC ticket.
Attendees: Don, Glen, Joanna, Riku, Dave R, Anton, Ben C, Xinyu, Matteo
Minutes:
- Action: Glen to merge Shebu and Joanna's priority lists into TFC
- Joanna: Gerrit labels couldn't be access labels. Created ticket
TFC-196.
- Anton: Need the Musca-b's updated. Also got 5 more mucsa-b's to send.
- Don: Do they need set up?
- Anton: Need one board w/ OTP, but need to confirm internally, so hold
off. Otherwise should just work.
- Ben C: TIcket?
- Action: Need to create tickets
- Anton: TFC-190, 183.
- Glen: R-pi workers getting updated as well
- Ben: Plan to get one on line today.
- Xinyu - really need 2-3 Musca-b's up to run in parallel so that
release isn't extended.
- Glen: Meeting slot - move to Wednesday at same time?
- Won't work, will investigate other possibilities
- Boards advancing
- MBed TLS - working thru authentication issues.
- Riku: Plan to switch to new Open CI authentication - must include
renaming some other jobs, but better than rewriting some MBed TLS code.
Will test this on staging server first.
don
Attendees: Shebu, Xinyu, Glen, Don, Anton, Ben C, Dave R
Minutes:
- Glen: Got Joanna's priority list, still need from Shebu
- Shebu: Have one now for TF-A and TF-M
- Anton: How many licenses are needed to run IAR on open CI?
- Glen: I recall that we changed the way licenses were attained. Not
sure on details, but will follow up
- Shebu to forward the priority list to Glen.
- Glen: For MBed TLE, using the same milestones previously developed.
Leonardo is working w/ Daryl(?) on the best way to implement rule-based
authentication in order to complete Milestone 3
-
https://linaro.atlassian.net/jira/software/c/projects/TFC/boards/70?modal=d…
- Team will be syncing up to determine the best way to implement
TFC-121
- Board status
- Theo picked up Chromebook in Cambridge
- Glen: NXP - resolving a flashing issue, expect to go live this week
- Shebu: Code freeze on 12th, so whatever is available in Open CI
will be used in release testing
- Glen: Cypress follows NXP
- Updates on Musca B?
- Ben: Goal is Nov 8, NXP was a priority last week.
- Shebu: Do need before Nov 8 code freeze date
-
- Glen: Still have Leo on the team, Theo and Paul spinning up. Theo
has been in ramp down but part-time last week. Theo helping to get boards
in LAVA
- Glen: The new list will be integrated with the new priorities,
TF-A/TF-M will be interleaved. Finish the In-Progress first.
- Shebu: Agreed
- TF-M Release info
-
plan to start the process from Nov 15
-
Release target date: Nov 26
-
This time we plan to use a separate Release branch and avoid code
freeze.
- Glen: TFC-188: Tuxput - don't see getting to this year.
Attendees: Glen, Xinyu, Riku, Don, Ben C, Anton, Joanna, Matteo
Minutes:
- Glen: Plugins? TFC-121 MBed TLS plugins
- Riku: Still working on it. STG-2633
- Glen: Staffing.
Theo onboard, setting up LAVA at home and will be integrating next
Chromebook.
Leonardo remains onboard for a bit more time, will continue on MBed
TLS.
Arthur getting NXP boards into LAVA as well as TFC-82 Github auth.
support to LAVA - patch applied, need LAVA update now
- Glen: Recent LAVA change creating a Code Coverage regression. Email
thread only. TF-A was working, now not. So a new ticket will be created
- Glen: backlog / sc-approved cleanup review
In progress: Reviewed, staffed, and all looks good
SC Approved: Expect script to be started w/ Paul
Several others are queued up.
TFC-29 - Joanna to check to see if this needs worked on. Matteo, also
want to visit backlog to see if higher priorities. Moved back to backlog.
- Anton: TFC-33 and 135 in backlog may be really simple - permission
changes
- Joanna: TFC-75 - would be good to start on this one, some sync issues
on gerrit. Hoping it's another quick one. Joanna to follow up and update
the ticket.
- Joanna to prioritize TF-A tickets in backlog then we'll prioritize
those against other backlog items
*Attendees*: Don, Joanna, Matteo, Xinyu, Riku, Janos Follath, Anton, Dave
Rodgman, Ben Copeland, Shebu
*Minutes*:
- Glen: Staffing - Updated team on the staffing updates
- Theo and Paul joining.
- Leonardo transitioning over the next few weeks.
- Glen to meet w/ whole team tomorrow
- Leonardo still best person to contact on MBedTSL
- MBedTLS
- M2 completed, M3 blocked on need for plugins
- Riku to take care of plugins, targeting today to complete
- TFC-176
- Still completing
- TFC-82: Arthur was working on this. Want his updates released and
should complete
- TFC-87: Arthur has been working w/ Joanna on this. May take a couple
of passes, but initial solution in the next day
- TFC-183 - MUSCA B are off line.
- Ben: Dave looking into this. Failed due to debian update and debian
bug.
- Glen: Back it out?
- Ben recommends moving forward and resolving in next sprint (next
week). Urgency?
- Anton: Only MUSCA B offline? Preparing for next month release, so
need by then for sure.
- Agreed to put in next week
- Glen: NXP Boards coming up in Lab
- Glen: Chromebooks (Jacuzi - TFC-45) received in Cambridge, got out of
customs!
- Glen: Creating card for next set of Chromebooks (Lazor)
- Glen: Renesas beginning to ship the h/w
- Shebu: Renesas Intend to push board support for TF-M
- Matteo: Any priority calls to make?
- Glen: Some of the smaller backlog tickets. Glen will be moving items
out of backlog and assigning them.
- Matteo: To draft an email on backlog email and share w/ Glen.
- Shebu: Some SC Approved have yet to be touched.
- How much effort for Disaster Recovery? It could be a larger task.
Will break this down into subtasks and do the assessment.
- ACTION: Joanna, Anton, Matteo, Shebu to go thru backlog and SC
approved and make adjustments in the Kanban. Keep others updated via email.
Attendees: Don, Riku, Xinyu, Shebu, Dave Rodgman, Ben, Joanna
Minutes:
- Several platforms ready to add to the Cambridge lab. Includes NXP,
Cyrpress, Google
- TFC-181: patches in review
- TFC-176: Continue to work. Moed from SC Approved to In Progress.
- May have a temporary fix from Leonardo.
- Monitoring at this point. Joanna recommends holding off on ticket
TFC-96 until TFC-176 is stable so as not to add more variables into the
solution. After a few days of stability, can come back to this.
- Moved TFC-36 to REOPENED and prioritized
- Moved TFC-36 to SC Approved
- Verify MBed status. Still in Blocked.
- Action: Don check w/ Glen/Leonardo as to why the Mbed work still in
"Blocked"
- Anything else to work on here?
- Joanna: TFC-87: Would be good to start if time allows. Doesn't have
to all be done at once.
- Shebu: Update on staffing
- Two engineerings from Linaro coming on to help for next 6 months to
supplement the staff. Theodore Grey & Paul Sokolovskyy (Welcome aboard!)
- Will want to make sure the team is appropriately loaded.
- Board additions will continue.
- MBedTLC CI up and running important too.
- Over the next couple of weeks Glen will be integrating them into
the team as they spin up.
*Attendees*: Don, Glen, Anton, Shebu, Matteo, Joanna, Ben C, Dave Rodgman,
Riku
*Minutes*:
- Servers went down - certificate expiration issue resolved. Blocker
- TFC-179/TFC-80 (duplicate) - certificates updated and these can be
resolved
- Glen: Adding boards:
- Have documentation on boards. Should we add vendor boards to
documentation?
- User's manual.
- Determine if public?
- Don: Assumed it was public.
- Shebu: Worth asking Eric, Julius, Sean, and others if they're OK to
do that.
- Glen: Can share what would be published in the User's Guide first.
- Would be OK to point to vendor info if works
- Anton: TF-A/M docs could also point to this
- Platform integration updates:
- Glen: Cypress/NXP in Cambridge. Will get integrated shortly.
- Google Chromebooks.
- Arthur and Fathi's returned to sender, the 3 platforms made it
to the lab.
- Working with Google to start the 2nd platform.
- MBedTLS
- Dave's team provided the AMI files.
- Dave: Darryl expected additional AMI's beyond Ubuntu image. Will
build additional configs from those after Ubuntu.
- TFC-176: Leonardo has a work-around (3 retries), but not getting to
root cause. Likely need a longer-term solution.
- Glen asking for Expect script review from Joanna.
- TFC-82: Github auth. Working, now looking to deploy.
- Anton: TF-M health check job. Expected OpenCI team to keep it up.
Sanity test is failing.
https://ci.trustedfirmware.org/view/TF-M/job/tf-m-infra-health/
- Don: Suggest creating a ticket.
- Action: Glen/Ben to open a ticket so that can track/assign.
Thanks
don
*Attendees*: Don, Glen, Anton, Riku, Joanna, Matteo, Xinyu, Dave Rodgman,
Shebu
*Minutes*:
- Glen: Shared TFC Board
- Boards:
- Chromebooks - returning to get out of customs and then sending back
again.
- Cypress/NXP being integrated in October. Received h/w in lab
- TFC-82: Arthur working on this while have time
- TFC-36 is ready for Arm team to review. Leonardo
- TFC-176: Intermittent failures. Leonardo continuing to isolate this
- TFC-20 integrated including a resolved regression. Any issues noticed?
- Arm provided AMI files. Go back to mbedTLS?
- Matteo: Will we finish TFC-36? Need to make sure this finishes.
- Glen: Agreed
- Joanna: Would like to continue w/ TFC-176 continue at least part
time.
- Glen recommends re-evaluating after his work day today
- Joanna: Agree to keep it as a background task
- TFC-172: In backlog, not any data in the ticket on quantifying slow
or how to replace.
- Xinyu: No longer reproducing. Xinyu to update ticket and we will
close
- TFC-171: Seems to be solved from other infrastructure improvements
- Joanna: OK to close resolved. Not sure what it was but not
occurring now
- Arthur may have bandwidth for another task
- Joanna: TFC-87 may be a good one to work on. Currently the team
performs a work-around.
- Moved TFC-87 to SC Approved from Backlog
- *Action: Anton* to evaluate moving TFC-173 to SC Approved.
Don
