September 2021 - Tf-openci-triage - lists.trustedfirmware.org

by Don Harbin

*Attendees*: Don, Glen, Anton, Riku, Joanna, Matteo, Xinyu, Dave Rodgman, Shebu *Minutes*: - Glen: Shared TFC Board - Boards: - Chromebooks - returning to get out of customs and then sending back again. - Cypress/NXP being integrated in October. Received h/w in lab - TFC-82: Arthur working on this while have time - TFC-36 is ready for Arm team to review. Leonardo - TFC-176: Intermittent failures. Leonardo continuing to isolate this - TFC-20 integrated including a resolved regression. Any issues noticed? - Arm provided AMI files. Go back to mbedTLS? - Matteo: Will we finish TFC-36? Need to make sure this finishes. - Glen: Agreed - Joanna: Would like to continue w/ TFC-176 continue at least part time. - Glen recommends re-evaluating after his work day today - Joanna: Agree to keep it as a background task - TFC-172: In backlog, not any data in the ticket on quantifying slow or how to replace. - Xinyu: No longer reproducing. Xinyu to update ticket and we will close - TFC-171: Seems to be solved from other infrastructure improvements - Joanna: OK to close resolved. Not sure what it was but not occurring now - Arthur may have bandwidth for another task - Joanna: TFC-87 may be a good one to work on. Currently the team performs a work-around. - Moved TFC-87 to SC Approved from Backlog - *Action: Anton* to evaluate moving TFC-173 to SC Approved. Don

2 years, 7 months

2
1
0 0

TF Triage Minutes Sept 21

by Don Harbin

Attendees: Riku, Don, Glen, Matteo, Shebu, Anton, Joanna, Dave Rodgman Minutes: - TFC-20: Git performance - infrastructure changes happened including Leonardo infrastructure changes. Tested on stage. Should keep an eye on it for next few days. New machine already added back in. Better performance will be seen as well since more jobs can focus on builds and not clones. - Expect scripts: Should wrap up this week - Joanna: Brought up LAVA timeouts TFC-176. Pass on 2nd or 3rd attempts. Initial analysis is too many parallel LAVA jobs. Starting out by increasing timeout. Would prevent re-running jobs. - Riku: Should add LAVA lab folks to this ticket since adjusting timeouts - Boards status: - Chromebooks still dealing w/ import issues. - *ACTION: Don* ask Julius to reject and resend the 3 boards to the Cambridge lab - Cypress and NXP platforms now in the lab - LAVA team will be updating to latest release with the new board configs included. Want this done in the next couple of weeks - Arthur will be available for some other tasks. - MBedTLS - Dave: AMI images almost ready. Expect it soon. - Glen: Linaro support prepared to copy to AMI's when they are queued up. - Glen: Joanna's new list of issues - LAVA timeout was one. - TFC-87: Joanna's team reviewing that one. CI reporting ticket. Need some guidance/access from Leonardo - Glen will let him know Thanks Don

2 years, 7 months

1
0
0 0

Weekly triage sync minutes - Sept 7

by Don Harbin

*Attendees*: Joanna, Xinyu, Matteo, Janos, Glen, Riku, Shebu, Anton, Ben, Don *Actions*: - Glen: Follow up on notes - Glen: Set up sync meeting to hear Riku/Leonardo/Anton/Joanna on proposing a solution on the git clone performance issue. *Minutes*: - Glen: TFC Kanban board review - Glen: Chromebooks stuck in customs - working paperwork now - Glen: Cypress & NXP platforms both underway - Glen: Performance issues update: (TFC-171, 172, 164) - Ben: Limited CI Number of jobs to help relieve a performance issue. - Riku: Impact - slower builds. - Anton: were we testing on staging? - Ben: No - Should we allocate resources to work on performance? - Joanna: Would work on server scaling versus Expect scripts - Riku: TF-M build, launches over 100 builds, then git clones turn into 400 simultaneous git clones - need to re-factor to do clone up front. - Riku/Leonardo - 1-2 week estimate - Anton has some ideas - sync w/ him on potential solution. Once agreed, begin the work. - Glen: Meeting set up for tomorrow to discuss code coverage state and how Arm might be able to help.

2 years, 7 months

4
3
0 0

Re: [Tf-openci-triage] FW: Code Coverage at TF-M

by Don Harbin

Hi Sherry, I'm adding the triage maillist to the thread. As a best practice, let's cc that list on items like this as it includes the stakeholders that prioritize OpenCI tasks on a weekly basis(minimum) so it's helpful info in that decision making. I see you're already subscribed to the list which is great! :) Reviewing the Aug 31st sync minutes, Expect scripts were determined to be the priority. Code Coverage next steps are also discussed. Looks like Glen was going to set up a sync meeting to further discuss this one... The minutes could have called out this action more clearly: - Code Coverage: - A sync w/ Leonardo and Joanna to discuss next steps/Current status on CC shall be planned. Glen to set up > Is it suspended for pure priority reason, or any technical reason? So with the above said, this is a prioritization decision made by the triage stakeholders, not technical. Hope this helps, please let me know if any questions or suggestions on improving the process. :) Best, don On Thu, 2 Sept 2021 at 06:35, Leonardo Sandoval < leonardo.sandoval(a)linaro.org> wrote: > Hi Sherry, > > In resume, for priority reasons. > > Right now I am working on some pending tickets for TF-A (expect scripts > migration, TFC-36 <https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-36>). Once I > complete TFC-36 <https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-36> and MbedTLS > work is still on hold, I will move to TFC-7 > <https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-7> immediately. > > Regards, > lsg > > > > On Thu, 2 Sept 2021 at 02:15, Sherry Wu <Sherry.Wu(a)arm.com> wrote: > >> Hi Leonardo and Don, >> >> >> >> Just noticed that https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-7 changed to >> “TODO”. Wondering what’s latest update for the code coverage tool >> integration on Open CI. >> > > Thanks, >> >> Sherry >> >> >> IMPORTANT NOTICE: The contents of this email and any attachments are >> confidential and may also be privileged. If you are not the intended >> recipient, please notify the sender immediately and do not disclose the >> contents to any other person, use it for any purpose, or store or copy the >> information in any medium. Thank you. >> >

2 years, 7 months

2
1
0 0

Re: [Tf-openci-triage] Trustedfirmware.org Getting Slow

by Don Harbin

Hi Xinyu, Thanks for the escalation. I see Ben is in the loop, so that's the correct first step. I've also cc'd the triage maillist to make sure all stakeholders are looped in. In general, as a best practice, I would suggest having as much quantifiable data as possible upfront in tickets like this to help better understand the magnitude as well as how to reproduce. It looks like the tickets have already started to capture this, but I also see Ben in the ticket requesting more. Datapoints of interest in my mind: - Clear details on how to reproduce: The task(s) where noticeable degradation is seen - is this in parallel to when large builds have kicked off? etc. - Tasks invoked and level of degradation: for example, "Gerrit reviews - previously took xyz seconds/minutes, now taking 20% more time (or 2x, 10x?, failing & never completing?)," frequency, etc. The more details the better! This will help determine the priority we place on resolving. :) Perhaps coming up with a general template for this could be helpful. - Is there other degradations beyond Gerrit? Ben is most certainly much more qualified than me in knowing what support is needed to isolate/resolve, and, as noted in the ticket, he is asking for more details as well. Let's get the details captured in the ticket(s) in preparation for next Tuesday's Triage meeting where we can prioritize the resolution over other TFC tasks. :) Ben, feel free to chime in and correct any of my assumptions/suggestions. Regards, Don On Thu, 2 Sept 2021 at 01:41, Xinyu Zhang <Xinyu.Zhang(a)arm.com> wrote: > Hi Don, > > > > We found that trustedfirmware.org is getting slow. Daily work of some > developers would be influenced. > > Could you please help to take a look on this issue? Here is the TFC link: > https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-172 > > > > BR, > > Xinyu > IMPORTANT NOTICE: The contents of this email and any attachments are > confidential and may also be privileged. If you are not the intended > recipient, please notify the sender immediately and do not disclose the > contents to any other person, use it for any purpose, or store or copy the > information in any medium. Thank you. >

2 years, 7 months

1
0
0 0

2024

2023

2022

2021

Tf-openci-triage September 2021