Hi All,
Please find the meeting minutes from yesterday below
Don
Attendees: Joanna, Don, Antonio, Ben, Glen, Xinyu, Shebu, Matteo, Dan
Handley
Minutes:
-
Upgrade for Production has been pushed to July 5th. Arthur She
<arthur.she(a)linaro.org> is on holiday and it makes sense to have him
back for testing.
-
Lab Hardware - Back boards?
-
Lab team has asked if there are any MPS boards?
-
AI: Anton to see about getting 1-2 spares
-
Recent issue TFC-293 <https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-293> -
Flakey stm32l562e
-
Arthur has 2 and will ship them when he returns home at the end of
July.
-
Joanna - is anyone doing anything with the Chrome Books.
-
Google should be creating boot tests and any other tests they
would like. AI: Don to follow up with Julian about setting up
tests. Also bring up at the board meeting. (Shebu brought up w/
NXP in the past.)
-
Jira https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-275 logged for what
needs to be setup.
-
Shebu - Its the partners responsibility to enable the testing.
-
Juno’s using netboot?
-
If your changing the firmware, netboot will not help.
-
Dean & Ben to follow up with a discussion about the details, may
be able to reduce the frequency of
-
mbedTLS
-
Shebu - Hosting mbedtls website content in tf.org
-
Old company removed all content, new company will need to redeploy.
-
Dean - Is it possible to migrate MbedTLS to TF.org domain?
-
TF is all hosted off GitHub (
https://github.com/TrustedFirmwareWebsite/website )
-
Current: https://www.trustedfirmware.org/projects/mbed-tls/
-
There is legacy content, knowledge base for coding style, examples.
-
Ben - convert the content as a pull request.
-
Shebu - readthedocs is more of a long term, short term is just to
drop it in somewhere.
-
Old Site - https://github.com/Mbed-TLS/polarssl_site (Private)
-
Blockers - cleaned up. 1 waiting for Paul to get back, 4 waiting on
Production update
-
Misra
- Updated Plan Milestones w/ dates.
Attendees: Joanna, Don, Antonio, Ben, Glen, Xinyu, Shebu, Matteo, Dan
Handley
Minutes:
-
Code Coverage: Closed?
-
Joanna: Was a bug, thought Paul fixed - will verify.
-
Xinyu: CC broken in TF-M.
-
Glen:
-
Paul on Holiday this week.
-
Next week, Monday, updating Prod to mirror Stage. 27th. Kelley will
post
-
Arthur will be on holiday 28th to the 4th. Verify 27th is still a
good date for the update w/ Arthur’s update.
-
ECLAIRE Next Steps
-
Don acquired of licenses (detachable)
-
M0 - Planning done, ~30 staff weeks total remaining.
-
Majority of work is Paul (16-18 staff months).
-
Systems side is 12-14 staff weeks.
-
Will Paul have time for other tasks?
-
Arthur will be available full time w/ no additional h/w in the queue.
-
Table didn’t have time view. How much can be done in Parallel? Will
it be done by October? Start putting in dates?
-
Glen add dates to milestones
-
Also define plan for what Arthur can complete this 6 month technology
-
Don: Blocker review
-
TFC-9: Move back to backlog. Contact? Linaro Security team.
-
TFC-16: Already have TF-247. Close TFC-16 as duplicate
-
TFC-17: TF-M. Antonio, already have a way to test per patch. Close
TFC-17 as OBE. Ping Anton first
-
TFC-18: Move to bottom of backlog per Shebu
-
Remaining blockers tied to Production upgrade, so should remain
-
Matteo: Compiler Licenses have been extended.
-
Forwarding note from Paul Black.
Action: Let board know there is no Open CI h/w backlog at this time.
June 7th
Attendees: Joanna, Anton, Don, Ben, Glen, Xinyu, Shebu, Matteo, Dave Rodgman
Action Items:
-
Action: Don to find Friday’s Bugseng meeting minutes and get them sent
out.
-
Sent out via email - 6/1 Re: Bugseng meeting last Friday?
Minutes
-
Linaro - Orginazation meetings next week 13th - 17th; People are out.
Paul is on holiday for 20th - 25th
-
Upgrade for Production & Stage Jenkins
-
Stage has been Updated
-
TF-A/M has completed release, will not need anything for about 6
months
-
Kelley is not in SFO, and will be monitoring
-
Issue with Multi-Job plugin, its deprecated, and may need to move to
something new.
-
Target for 27th of June.
-
TFC-260 Mbed TLS running slow - there are two things; bug in the docker
driver or the kernel version.
-
This work will happen after the Jenkins update has occurred.
-
Compiler issue with down
-
Send email to Matteo Carlini <matteo.carlini(a)arm.com> and Shebu on
what the issue is and he can send this up to his management.
-
MISRA Milestone status; Document is under Review, will provide the
Milestones when available.
-
Email of various issue from Matteo - need to assign ARM issue to Joanna
-
Ran out of time… we have blockers that need a review, some are
old. Agreed that some of these may be OBE(overcome by events), but need to
review and make sure any blockers are being worked.
May 31
Attendees: Xinyu, Shebu, Don, Dave Rodgman, Matteo, Anton
Action Items:
-
Action: Don to find Friday’s Bugseng meeting minutes and get them sent
out.
Minutes:
-
Shebu: Update on Bugseng topic
-
Don to see where the meeting minutes are.
-
Joanna: *TFC-270*. Some can use it, one developer can’t. Work to
clear this.
-
Joann: A false positive bug in release. Fails in LAVA but not rolled
up. *TFC-269*. Now recurs.
-
MISRA Document
-
Joanna has reviewed, Madhu commented, Sandrine still to walk thru and
provide comments.
-
Anton: *TFC-268* would be helpful to get done, should be small since a
folder has been excluded.
-
Anton: All MPS2 board in Maintenance. *TFC-271*
-
Don moved all four tickets above to SC Approved
Attendees: Don, Ben, Anton, Xinyu, Antonio, Anton K, Shebu, Glen, Dave R,
Matteo
Action Items:
-
Glen: Setting up sync with Bugseng to review MISRA planning doc. Done
Minutes:
-
MISRA
-
Meeting w/ Paul & Fathi last week
-
Awaiting review/response from ARM; Joanna reviewed this morning. A
couple of comments, will share.
-
Shebu: Should not start until a milestone review
-
Matteo: Would like to see Arthur and Paul on other tasks. Need to
see milestones laid out.
-
Would TF-M, and other following be able to leverage work done by TF-A
efforts?
-
Don: yes, expect a reasonable amount of reuse.
-
Share document w/ Anton.
-
Would like to review this with Bugseng.
-
Update the document w/ the estimates after sync w/ Bugseng
-
MBed TLS
-
Merged Windows changes last week, in monitoring mode for next month.
-
Will start some more accurate infrastructure cost is
-
Dave: Things seem good and performant.
-
TF-M
-
PSA tests. Paul is blocked by license. Follow up with Anton
-
Ticket 268 - configure test cover, simple low hanging. If this can
be done quickly, that would be helpful
The maillist dropped my attachment it looks like. Let me try this again.
Don
---------- Forwarded message ---------
From: Glen Valante <glen.valante(a)linaro.org>
Date: Tue, 17 May 2022 at 18:23
Subject: Re: [Tf-openci-triage] May Open CI Board slides
To: Don Harbin <don.harbin(a)linaro.org>
pssst... where are they?
-g
On 5/17/2022 7:10 PM, Don Harbin via Tf-openci-triage wrote:
Hi,
Please find the Open CI Board slides from last week's board meeting.
Best
Don
--
[image: Linaro] <http://www.linaro.org>
Glen Valante | *Sr. Technical Program Manager*
T: +1.508.517.3461 <1617-320-5000>
glen.valante(a)linaro.org | Skype: gvalante <callto:gvalante>
Attendees:
-
Xinyu, Ben C, Don, Joanna, Matteo,
Action Items:
-
Action: Dave to follow up on status of the AMI prebuilt from legal review
-
Action: Don, start sharing the Open CI slides from the Board Deck (no
financial slides, etc.)
Minutes:
-
Joanna’s Action: Windows Commonality response from Joanna between TFC-14
and TFC-129. Response is “no commonality” Arthur provided input.
-
Bugseng tool announced.
-
Matteo: Where in terms of updating ticket TFC-10
-
Ben: Fathi drafting a proposal. Follow on sync w/ Fathi tomorrow.
Have an early draft. Paul also working on it as well.
-
Matteo: Also some intervention from TF-A team. Top down requirements
-
Don: Follow on sync set up for this Friday.
-
Joanna: Want to make sure submitted patches don’t make things worse.
More than one build option.
-
Don: Reminder that we have some support hours, so can set up set up a
sync w/ Bugseng
-
Joanna: TF-A team have passed links on to Paul. Madhu had follow ups
w/ Account ID’s etc.
-
Ben talk to Fathi on ticket update.
-
Don: Mbed TLS update
-
Don: Have the connection issue and getting Windows SDK installed.
Waiting on a Windows AMI prebuilt from Dave’s team.
-
Action: Dave to follow up on status of the AMI prebuilt from legal
review
-
Dave: Also evaluated a reduction of the number of jobs to help
performance.
-
Action: Don, start sharing the Open CI slides from the Board Deck (no
financial slides)
May 3
Attendees: Matteo, Don, Shebu, Antonio, Dave Rodgman <dave.rodgman(a)arm.com>
Action: Action: Don, check with Joanna to see if there Is commonality
between TFC-14 and TFC-129? Windows tests/builds for TF-A and Mbed TLS. Is
the build environment reuseable? Note Joanna is out this week
Minutes:
-
Shebu: Issues regarding slow CI.
-
Don: MBed TLS - Executor # increased to get thru the queue. Not sure if
it’s been completed yet
-
Dave: Quick scan showing the queue burning down.
-
Shebu: TF-M side, tests being run.
-
Antonio: TF-M was looking good Friday.
-
Held MISRA tooling meeting last week. No ticket updates. Need to
update tickets.
-
TF-A first. TF-M will be handled separately.
-
Shebu: TF-M is marked for next quarter.
-
Don: Noted serial - after TF-A.
-
MBed TLS
-
Moving forward on Windows 11, raised the priority
-
Action: Don, check with Joanna to see if there Is commonality between
TFC-14 and TFC-129? Windows tests/builds for TF-A and Mbed TLS. Is the
build environment reuseable? Note Joanna is out this week.
-
TFC-251: Want to prioritise the documentation so that developer docs are
….
-
TFC-247: Must determine who mirrors the repo prior to configuring the
scripts. Dev team vs Open CI dev team.
-
Don added a note to TFC-184 to understand status of 3rd Lazor. Moved to
Resolved.
Attendees: Don, Glen, Joanna, Antonio, Ben, Dave R, Matteo, Shebu, Xinyu
Minutes:
-
Update
-
Arthur - Mbed TLS working on windows, FreeBSD confirmed w/ team
-
Paul wrapped up CodeCoverage; PSA Testing
-
Theo working on boards, still waiting to hear from ST
-
Performance is slow
-
Dave R / Xinyu - Mbed TLS running slowly; seeing some time outs
-
One build that has been running 19hrs.
https://github.com/Mbed-TLS/mbedtls/pull/5742
-
Xinyu - TF-M also appears to be running a bit slow.
-
https://ci.trustedfirmware.org/view/TF-M/job/tf-m-nightly/922/
-
Action: Glen log a ticket on infrastructure running slow - TFC-260
<https://linaro.atlassian.net/browse/TFC-260>
-
Discuss MISRA Planning sync - looking to have a meeting set for Friday.
Joanna & Sandrine can attend. Awaiting to hear back from Paul.
-
Start with TF-A, follow on with TF-M after that.
-
PSA Compliance Tests, TFC-1, why in SC Approved? Will check, should be
In-Progress
-
MbedTLS - inquiry from ST, Shebu will provide a response. Dave’s team
is working on a change that can potentially reduce the overall cost.
-
Retrospective on maintenance
-
Ben, security fix. A bug in Jenkins only on Prod. No root cause
found, so rolled back. Working to reproduce in staging, but haven’t done
so yet.
-
Was Jenkins maintenance planned or security reasons?
-
Ben: Was planned with notices, but was also a security fix
-
Message was sent out to TF-Triage mail list
-
https://lists.trustedfirmware.org/archives/list/tf-openci-triage@lists.trus…
-
Consider a new list for updates
-
The slow down? That looks unrelated.
-
Releases
-
TF-A - slipped the release to the middle of May with completion at
the end of the month
-
TF-M - release should complete by the end of this week.
- CI Documentation - Joanna Farley <joanna.farley(a)arm.com> they will
add a new section (CI Developer) to the current documentation. Should
grow organically and when Linaro can add to the documents.
<end>
