Hi All,
The next release of the Firmware-A bundle of projects tagged v2.10 has an expected code freeze date of Nov, 7th 2023.
Refer to the Release Cadence section from TF-A documentation (https://git.trustedfirmware.org/TF-A/trusted-firmware-a.git/tree/docs/about…).
Closing out the release takes around 6-10 working days after the code freeze.
Preparations tasks for v2.10 release should start in coming month.
We want to ensure that planned feature patches for the release are submitted in good time for the review process to conclude. As a kind recommendation and a matter of sharing CI resources, please launch CI jobs with care e.g.:
-For simple platform, docs changes, or one liners, use Allow-CI+1 label (no need for a full Allow-CI+2 run).
-For large patch stacks use Allow-CI+2 at top of the patch stack (and if required few individual Allow+CI+1 in the middle of the patch stack).
-Carefully analyze results and fix the change if required, before launching new jobs on the same change.
-If after issuing a Allow-CI+1 or Allow-CI+2 label a Build start notice is not added as a gerrit comment on the patch right away please be patient as under heavy load CI jobs can be queued and in extreme conditions it can be over an hour before the Build start notice is issued. Issuing another Allow-CI+1 or Allow-CI+2 label will just result in an additional job being queued.
Thanks & Regards,
Olivier.
Hi,
Patrick has sent 2 correction patches for PSCI stack in OSI mode there:
https://review.trustedfirmware.org/q/topic:%22fix_psci_osi%22
But when running CI+2, there are 2 platforms for which 2 PSCI OSI tests
are failing:
fvp-ext-pstate-ea-el3|fvp-default|fvp-tftf-fip.tftf-cortexa57x4a53x4-debug
fvp-ext-pstate-ea-el3|fvp-default|fvp-tftf-fip.tftf-aemv8a-debug
I'm not familiar with those test configs, but when checking lava logs,
I see those traces for failing tests:
2024-01-11T14:21:59 > Executing 'CPU suspend to powerdown at level 1 in
OSI mode'
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:21:59 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:00 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 TEST COMPLETE Failed
2024-01-11T14:22:03 Wrong value: expected 0, got -3
2024-01-11T14:22:03 > Executing 'CPU suspend to powerdown at level 2 in
OSI mode'
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Booting
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Registered IRQ handler 0x8801b274 for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Going into suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Saving system context
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Unregistered IRQ handler for IRQ #7
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Powering off
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Restoring system context
2024-01-11T14:22:03 INFO: Resumed from suspend state
2024-01-11T14:22:03 TEST COMPLETE Failed
2024-01-11T14:22:03 Wrong value: expected 0, got -3
The "Resumed from suspend state" message interleaved with "Going into
suspend state" seem strange, but I cannot say what could be wrong there.
Maybe there is something wrong with the TF-A patches?
Or the platforms tests or configs need to be updated?
If you have any clue that would be very helpful!
Thanks,
Yann
